Black Friday Discrepancy

This Friday started really good! Good meetings – interesting cases – and soon weekend …

But then a case hit my mailbox. The sender (an LC officer at a bank) told me about a discussion with another bank – regarding this other bank refusal of document presented under an LC – basically asking for some arguments to support their case.

I get many of those – so I started reading the correspondence as I normally would … but – as I progressed I became increasingly sad…

Here is a (neutral) overview of the case:

LC field 50 Applicant:

Textiles inc.
Garment street 88
Country X

A presentation was made – including an invoice. This one showed in the top left corner:



Textiles inc.
Garment street 88
Country X


And then came the refusal from the bank:

“Invoice not made out in the name of the applicant.”

The presenter argued that it surely is. However NOT according to the issuing bank who “defended” their refusal by saying:

“There is no indication of “applicant” on the face of the invoice. The word “applicant” is not indicated. We cannot know who applicant is. There is just a name of a company, which is not consistent with “applicant,” “Buyer” is not always consistent with applicant, so this is definitely a discrepancy and deduction of USD 80 is right”

Oh my god!!!!

This is wrong for so many reasons that I do not bother mentioning them here … I am sure you know.

So I will only say this:

Perhaps the Trade Finance banks really do deserve that the LC ceases to exist. With handling like this no wonder why corporate customer do not bother working with LCs …

So – I have sadly marked this day in my calendar as “Black Friday Discrepancy” … it was on this very day that the ultimate murder attack was made on the LC.

Have a great weekend, take care of each other – and especially the LC … there are some really ignorant people out there trying really hard to kill it …

Best regards



Please Login to Leave Your Comment

Viewer's Recent Comments

Be the first to make a comment.

What's Inside

Login To LCViews

   Email Address

   Remember   Forgot Password

Latest Blog Post

Fob, Fca And The Incoterms In The Pipeline
The High Risk Ghost In Trade Finance
Combating Trade Based Money Laundering: Rethinking The Approach
The New Icc Opinions Are Out
The Ucp 600 Revision – Now You See It. Now You Don’t

Latest Single Window Questions

Lc Confirmation
Refusal To Negotiate Documents By A Nominated Bank
Definition Of Shipping Company
Ta629 And Isbp D8
Cost Additional To Freight

LCViews - Black Friday Discrepancy